Skip to main content

"apples and oranges"

With fruit, it's easy... it's either an apple or it's not. With cars, it's tough because an Accord is not an Impala which is not a Fusion which is not an Optima. Now take oranges (the color, not the fruit). If it's an orange XV Crosstrek it's good but if it's an orange RDX it's positively auction-proof. My point is, how can similar cars differ so much in value? Within one segment such as the Accord, Impala, Fusion, Optima sample... each of these sedans fit essentially the same niche. Yet, [a] group of 2012 Accord EX sedans sold at [a] auction on [one] day can vary $2,000. And the same can be said for the Impala, Fusion and Optima. Now consider a composite of vehicles; say a multi-franchise, multiple location new car dealers' entire pre-owned inventory that that dealers management calls its ACV at $11,450,000. That is to say, that if all 760 units in its inventory were cashed today, they would get a check back for the 11.4 million. What are the odds would you guess that they get back the 11.4? Or is it more reasonable to use a percentage of the total, like say, 95%? Or use 102%, 91%... what ever figure. But how best to derive at that number without auctioning each single unit off? What if there was a willing buyer for the total package and that buyer valued the composite based on what he or she thought they would have to pay for each one at auction? What percentage of the 11.4 million would that be? Less, right! Probably and that's because the sample principal that's been in effect for ever is at work here: the owner of [a] car always thinks its worth more! As for apples and oranges... take your pick... they're both good for you! W/

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Late Winter Market

It's not the northeast weather that is keeping the wholesale market in check, it is the overall blanket of slow retail sales at both new and used car retailers! * Subaru product is the most in demand at auction now, Hyundai another sought after product line. * Toyota shows increased prices on non-recall units, but not as strong as you might assume... more trouble ahead for the giant retailer? * The availability (or pure #'s of units) crossing the block is down at auctions overall; and the old economics 101... supply v. demand... is not at work right now. * As stated last post, large trucks are softening, luxury SUV's firm. * Honda Civic strong, Buick (yes, Buick) in demand: 2004 LeSabre LIMITED with 44K sells at an astonishing $9900. Compare that to a 58K 2004 Toyota Camry selling at $8900! Go Buick, go. * It is the economy, stupid. When it is all said, people are not grabbing out for another or new car. We are in a replacement mode at auction- that's it. Chat soon

Friday afternoon

No auction today... a break in what has been a very busy 2 months with so much movement recently that a day away from the block is like a 2 week vacation! There is so much talk about where the cars are and what will happen next that taking this time to type away helps me balance out what I've seen since the snow melted. Most noticeable to me is the overwhelming demand for trucks... pick ups. Dodge/Ram pound for pound is the monster at market currently and if it is Cummins equipped, you cant guess high enough. Next are the half-ton Lariat and LTZ type Ford and GM trucks with gas motors, leather, NAV... chrome. Miles here aren't as important as equipment... the more the higher they go. The next segment of Dakota, Tacoma, Ranger, Colorado are equally sought after and because of lessor quantities, an 01 Ranger XLT 4X4 6-cylinder 4-door beauty with 54K miles still commands over $6000. The bottom line is that people are still working and need to move dirt and sheet rock and to...

It's really much easier to understand!

In response to National Automobile Dealers Association’s chief economist Paul Taylor's comments, "Used Market Helping to Spur New-Car Growth" (Auto Remarketing Today, 12-3-10), I thought I would offer a bit of my own analysis. The increase in new vehicle sales is much easier to understand because the public buying decision has been so dumbed-down: $0 down $0 interest for as many months as you want! This alternative to fleet sales and endlessly evolving lease deals on the car makers part is very practical because "borrowing" sales now actually builds future availability of used product (Nissan Altima, Hyundai Sonata, and Honda Accord for example). And when these $179/mo models begin to come back to market, the very same marketers will already have in place a slightly different segment of new models at attractive discounted rates, there by repeating the cycle! Mr Taylor's analysis as a "shortage" in used vehicles should really have been branded as a...